Link graphic for a KJB version Bible Verse that will be automatically updated when we update it from time to time
">


7th Rangers
 
Fighting Seventh
The Fighting Rangers
On War, Politics
and Burning Issues
Profile
Miscellaneous

Kaffirphobia
American Thinker
American
Newspapers Online

Arab News
Asia News
Asia Times
Assyrian News
BBC News
Breitbart News
British and
International
Newspapers Online

CAMERA
CBS News
City Journal
CNN
Christian Solidarity
International

Daily Caller
Daily Mail
DAP Malaysia
Dawn
Drudge Report
Dutch News
Faith Freedom
Ali Sina

Foreign Affairs
Forward
Fox News
Google News
GK Ganesan Legal
Ground News
Guardian
Haaretz
Harakah Daily
English

Herald Malaysia
Hurriyet Turkey
History of Jihad
Independent
Indian Newspapers
Online

Inspire Magazine
Infidel Awareness
IPOH Echo
International
Herald Tribune

Jerusalem Newswire
Jihad Watch
Local-
French News
In English)

London Times
Malaysiakini

Malaysian Insider
Malaysia
Centre for Policy
Initiatives

Free Malaysia Today
Malaysia Chronicle
Malaysia
-Sarawak Report

MEMRI TV
Middle East
Forum

Mission Network
News

MSNBC News
National Review
NEWSMAX
New York Post
New York Times
Nut Graph
Opinion Journal
Right Wing News
Spiegel
Star Online
Straits Times
Sun Malaysia
Sydney
Morning Herald

Telegraph
The Malay Mail
The Rebel Media
The Sun (UK)
Time
Times of India
Town Hall
US News
World Report

USA Today
VBS TV
Washington Post
Washington Times
World Net Daily
World
Watch Monitor

Yahoo News
Ynet News



No Atheists
In A Foxhole

Rudyard Kipling

" “When you're left wounded on
Afganistan's plains and

the women come out to cut up what remains,
Just roll to your rifle

and blow out your brains,
And go to your God like a soldier”
General Douglas MacArthur

" “We are not retreating. We are advancing in another direction.”

“It is fatal to enter any war without the will to win it.”
“Old soldiers never die; they just fade away.
“The soldier, above all other people, prays for peace,
for he must suffer and be the deepest wounds and scars of war.”
“May God have mercy upon my enemies, because I won't .”
“The object of war is not to die for your country but to make the other bastard die for his.

“Nobody ever defended, there is only attack and attack and attack some more.
“It is foolish and wrong to mourn the men who died.
Rather we should thank God that such men lived.
The Soldier stood and faced God
Which must always come to pass
He hoped his shoes were shining
Just as bright as his brass
"Step forward you Soldier,
How shall I deal with you?
Have you always turned the other cheek?
To My Church have you been true?"
"No, Lord, I guess I ain't
Because those of us who carry guns
Can't always be a saint."
I've had to work on Sundays
And at times my talk was tough,
And sometimes I've been violent,
Because the world is awfully rough.
But, I never took a penny
That wasn't mine to keep.
Though I worked a lot of overtime
When the bills got just too steep,
The Soldier squared his shoulders and said
And I never passed a cry for help
Though at times I shook with fear,
And sometimes, God forgive me,
I've wept unmanly tears.
I know I don't deserve a place
Among the people here.
They never wanted me around
Except to calm their fears.
If you've a place for me here,
Lord, It needn't be so grand,
I never expected or had too much,
But if you don't, I'll understand."
There was silence all around the throne
Where the saints had often trod
As the Soldier waited quietly,
For the judgment of his God.
"Step forward now, you Soldier,
You've borne your burden well.
Walk peacefully on Heaven's streets,
You've done your time in Hell."

Proud To Have
Served With Warriors

Glorious
Malaysian Food
Foreign Bloggers + 1 Sarawakian
&
Other Stuff
Gaming

Major D Swami
WITH Lt Col Ivan Lee
Click Here

Lt Col Ivan Lee
you want him with
you in a firefight!!!!

Dying Warrior
xxxxxx
Condors-Infantry
Fighting Vehicles
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Camp
Bujang Senang
Click Here
xxxxxxxx
The A Team
Click Here
xxxxxxxx
Major General
Toh Choon Siang
Click here
Lieutenant General
Stephen Mundaw
Click Here
With His
Dying Breath
Killed in Battle
In Death
Last Thoughts
Before Battle
Whilst There Is
Life, There Is Fight

Not Done In Yet!!

Iban Trackers
XXXXXXXX
Facts On RoP
Hutang Negara
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Leadership and Military Analysis "We Captured the Enemy Brigade Commander" – Page 199
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Representative Image

A Path Less Taken — A Soldier’s Story Exigent Circumstances, Details On How To Purchase This Book, Click Here. 

This is one of the more revealing episodes in the book because it demonstrates several important qualities of an effective infantry battalion: physical endurance, tactical initiative, speed of movement, deception, junior leadership and, perhaps most importantly, the willingness of soldiers to look after one another.

But there is a deeper lesson here. The 7th Rangers defeated the enemy's expectations before they defeated the enemy's operational plan. The Division Headquarters expected the Rangers to take approximately a week to reach Gua Musang.

Major Muhammad Sultan bin Ismail predicted four days. The battalion accomplished the movement in three days and nights, despite difficult terrain, inadequate sleep, extreme heat and considerable physical discomfort. This was not simply a test of marching ability. It was a demonstration of operational tempo and the ability to exploit an enemy's incorrect assumptions.

1. Operational planning: Two different approaches to reaching Gua Musang

The exercise involved three friendly formations:

- New Zealand forces.

- Royal Malay Regiment.

- 7th Rangers.

They constituted the Blue Force under 4th Brigade. The opposing Red Force was 8th Brigade. The difference in approach was significant.

Formation - Method of advance

Royal Malay Regiment - Vehicle movement along the road

New Zealand forces - Vehicle movement along the road

7th Rangers - Foot movement cross-country

The Rangers had to cover approximately 117 kilometres, compared with 95.3 kilometres by road. This imposed a considerably greater physical burden on the infantry.

The Rangers had to negotiate:

- Young oil palm plantations.

- Numerous streams and rivers.

- Hills and difficult cross-country terrain.

- Intense tropical heat.

- Limited opportunities for proper rest.

- The burden of combat rations and full battle order.

Leadership lesson

A good infantry commander must understand the relationship between terrain, distance, time and the physical condition of his soldiers. A movement that appears achievable on a map can become considerably more difficult when soldiers are carrying combat equipment through tropical terrain. The ability to translate a map-based plan into practical movement on the ground is an essential command skill.

2. The psychology of underestimation: The enemy's greatest mistake

This is arguably the most important operational lesson in the episode. Division Headquarters was betting that the 7th Rangers would require a week to reach Gua Musang. Major Muhammad Sultan predicted four days.

The Rangers arrived in three days and nights. Why was this important? Because the Red Force had formed its expectations around conventional assumptions about the Rangers' movement.

It believed that the battalion was still a considerable distance away. Consequently, its personnel and movements were exposed to a force that was much closer than anticipated. The Rangers exploited this psychological advantage. The enemy's assessment of the situation was wrong, and the Rangers benefited from that error.

This illustrates three principles:

1. Never assume that an opposing force will move at the speed you expect.

2. Never confuse difficult terrain with an absolute obstacle.

3. Never allow an enemy to dictate your operational tempo through his expectations.

The author's observation that assumptions are the mother of all fuck-ups is crude military language, but it captures a serious operational truth.

3. Tactical initiative: Capturing the enemy's convoy

The encounter with the 8th Brigade Military Police is particularly interesting. The Rangers encountered a Land Rover with Military Police personnel in a rubber plantation. The Military Police realised that the Rangers were the opposing force and fled.

The Rangers gave chase and fired blank ammunition. Subsequently, a convoy of two trucks carrying freshly cooked food for 8th Brigade's forward troops passed through the area. The Rangers captured both trucks, their occupants and their food.

The soldiers then ate the food intended for their opponents. There are several leadership and tactical lessons here.

Situational awareness: The Rangers recognised an opportunity when the enemy's movements exposed personnel and logistical resources.

Initiative: They acted rather than simply continuing their planned movement without considering the immediate tactical situation.

Psychological impact: The capture demonstrated that the Rangers had penetrated much further into the enemy's operating area than anticipated. Logistical vulnerability: Even in an exercise, the incident illustrated how vulnerable supply movements can become when an opposing force operates beyond expected positions.

An infantry commander should never regard logistics as separate from tactical operations. Food, ammunition, transport and communications all influence operational effectiveness.

4. The capture of the 8th Brigade Commander: A corporal's initiative

This is perhaps the most entertaining and revealing incident in the entire account. The enemy Brigade Commander, apparently believing that the Rangers were still far away, drove past a fighting section of approximately ten soldiers commanded by Corporal Jack Minan. Jack Minan hurled a thunderflash at the staff car.

The Brigade Commander stopped, got out and angrily demanded to know whether the corporal knew who he was.

The reply was remarkable: "General or not general, do you want to be captured or killed sir?" It is a wonderful illustration of the difference between rank and battlefield circumstances. What does this incident teach us?

A. Junior leaders must be empowered. Corporal Jack Minan did not need to wait for instructions from battalion headquarters to react to an immediate tactical situation. He assessed what was happening and acted.

B. Situational awareness is more important than status. The Brigade Commander apparently failed to appreciate that he was moving through an area where an enemy fighting section was operating. His appointment did not protect him from the consequences of poor situational awareness.

C. Tactical opportunities can arise unexpectedly.

The Rangers had not necessarily planned to capture the Brigade Commander personally. The opportunity presented itself, and the fighting section reacted.

D. Discipline must survive the excitement of success.

Jack Minan's response was direct, but he maintained the essential military relationship by addressing the Brigade Commander respectfully. There is an important distinction here: initiative does not mean indiscipline. A good soldier can act decisively while maintaining military professionalism.

A lesson for young infantry officers

Do not underestimate the intelligence, initiative and judgement of your non-commissioned officers. A corporal commanding ten men can make a decision that has consequences far beyond his immediate section. A commander who suppresses initiative at the lowest level will eventually discover that his soldiers have become dependent on instructions rather than capable of thinking for themselves.

5. The UCIS Platoon: The importance of specialist capabilities

The author specifically acknowledges that the UCIS Platoon was leading the advance. This is an important detail. The success of the movement was not simply the result of physical toughness. It also involved the employment of a specialised reconnaissance capability.

The platoon was commanded by another younger officer who had also qualified at the Special Warfare Training Centre. This raises an important point about military leadership: A commander must recognise and employ the specialist capabilities available within his formation.

The successful employment of a specialist platoon can improve:

- Ground appreciation.

- Route selection.

- Early warning.

- Identification of enemy activity.

- The battalion's ability to maintain momentum.

- The commander's understanding of the tactical situation.

The author's acknowledgement that the UCIS commander was someone else is also noteworthy. He does not claim credit for another officer's contribution. That is an important leadership quality: recognising the work of others rather than appropriating their achievements.

6. Physical endurance: Leadership under personal adversity

For me, this is the most human dimension of the account. The author was suffering from:

- Swollen and painful knees.

- Severe inner-thigh chafing caused by prolonged friction.

- Dehydration and thirst.

- Physical exhaustion.

- Insufficient sleep over three days and nights.

Yet he completed the 117-kilometre cross-country movement. This deserves examination because there is a difference between describing endurance and demonstrating what endurance actually involves. The author does not portray himself as physically invulnerable. He acknowledges his pain and difficulties.

That makes the account more credible as a leadership lesson. The distinction between toughness and resilience Toughness is the ability to tolerate discomfort.

Resilience involves continuing to function despite adversity, adapting to circumstances and accepting assistance when necessary. The author demonstrated the latter. He did not complete the journey entirely through individual determination. He received help from two Rangers. This brings us to an even more important aspect of the story.

7. Rangers Tararasen and Ducy Sid: The meaning of comradeship

The closing paragraph is arguably the most powerful part of the entire passage. The author writes that Rangers Tararasen and Ducy Sid helped him complete the route.

They: - Helped carry his load.

- Cooked for him.

- Prepared his resting place.

- Stayed with him despite his physical difficulties.

- Supported him throughout the demanding movement.

The author's acknowledgement is significant. He openly admits that without their assistance, he might not have completed the route. This is an important departure from the conventional image of the military leader as an individual who must always demonstrate strength and independence.

A good leader must also recognise when he needs help. What does this reveal about the relationship between officers and soldiers? It reveals something that cannot be established through rank, regulations or military ceremonies. It is mutual commitment.

The officer had responsibilities towards his soldiers, but the soldiers also demonstrated genuine concern for their officer. Their assistance was not merely a matter of carrying equipment. It reflected a relationship developed through shared experiences and mutual trust.

The two Rangers did not abandon him when he was physically struggling. They stayed with him. This is the essence of military camaraderie. A soldier's loyalty is often most visible when another soldier is at his weakest.

There is also an important command lesson: accepting assistance from subordinates does not diminish an officer's authority. It can strengthen the mutual respect on which effective leadership depends.

8. The Division Commander's disrupted exercise plan

The reaction of the General Officer Commanding (GOC) is another interesting aspect. The exercise had been planned around particular assumptions concerning the movement of the participating formations. The 7th Rangers' rapid cross-country advance disrupted those assumptions.

The GOC was reportedly flabbergasted. The New Zealanders were also surprised by the Rangers' speed. This demonstrates an important principle of military exercises: An exercise should test a formation's ability to adapt to unexpected developments, not simply its ability to follow a predetermined script.

The Rangers exposed a weakness in the exercise planning assumptions. They demonstrated that a formation's actual capabilities can differ substantially from what higher headquarters anticipates. There is a lesson here for senior commanders as well: Never become so attached to an operational plan that you mistake your assumptions for reality.

9. Leadership lessons extracted from Page 199

Leadership quality - Evidence from the episode

Operational initiative - Rangers advanced cross-country and exploited opportunities

Physical resilience - The battalion completed 117 km in three days and nights

Tactical awareness - Convoy and Brigade Commander incidents

Junior leadership - Corporal Jack Minan's decisive response

Specialist competence - UCIS Platoon leading the advance

Humility - Author acknowledges the contribution of another platoon commander

Mutual trust - Tararasen and Ducy Sid supported the author

Comradeship - Soldiers helped an officer through physical adversity

Adaptability - Rangers disrupted the enemy's expectations Recognition Author openly credits his soldiers

10. A critical perspective: What should military instructors examine?

Although this was a successful exercise, it should not be treated as a recommendation to push soldiers beyond safe physical limits. There are several issues worth examining in a professional leadership discussion.

First: Physical conditioning. A 117-kilometre movement in full battle order requires preparation, appropriate pacing, hydration and injury management.

Second: Command responsibility. The author's swollen knees and severe chafing illustrate the physical consequences of prolonged movement. Commanders must distinguish between encouraging resilience and neglecting preventable injuries.

Third: Sleep deprivation. Three days and nights with very little sleep might demonstrate determination, but prolonged sleep deprivation can impair judgement, coordination and operational effectiveness.

Fourth: Training realism. The capture of the Brigade Commander and the logistical convoy demonstrates the importance of security, reconnaissance and realistic opposing-force activity. However, an exercise capture should not automatically be equated with success in actual combat.

These qualifications make the episode more useful as a teaching case because they encourage officers to examine both achievement and risk.

11. My overall assessment: What makes Page 199 particularly valuable?

I would highlight three different levels of leadership demonstrated in this account.

Level 1

Operational leadership

The battalion demonstrated the ability to move faster than anticipated, exploit opportunities and disrupt the enemy's planning assumptions.

Level 2

Tactical leadership

Corporal Jack Minan demonstrated initiative at section level. The UCIS Platoon demonstrated the importance of specialist capabilities.

Level 3

Human leadership

Tararasen and Ducy Sid demonstrated that loyalty and comradeship are not merely military expressions. They are demonstrated through actions, particularly when someone is struggling.

The deeper message: The officer is not always the strongest person in the column This is where I believe the passage has considerable literary and leadership value.

The author was an officer who had to depend on two of his soldiers to complete the march. He does not conceal this. He acknowledges their contribution and openly states that without them he might not have completed the journey.

That admission is important. Some military autobiographies concentrate on the achievements of the commanding officer. Here, the author gives recognition to the soldiers who helped him. That tells us something about his understanding of leadership.

A commission gives an officer authority, but it does not make him physically superior, intellectually infallible or independent of his men. The relationship between an officer and his soldiers must be reciprocal.

The officer leads, protects, trains and takes responsibility. His soldiers, in turn, provide commitment, trust and support. This is what builds a cohesive infantry unit.

12. A proposed concluding passage for the case study

The 7th Rangers: An example of operational initiative and comradeship The Taiaha Tombak exercise provides a compelling illustration of the importance of operational tempo, tactical initiative and physical resilience in infantry operations.

The 7th Rangers challenged the assumptions of higher headquarters by completing a difficult cross-country advance substantially faster than anticipated. Their progress disrupted the Red Force's expectations and exposed weaknesses in its security and situational awareness.

The capture of the enemy convoy and Brigade Commander demonstrated how opportunities can arise unexpectedly when a formation advances aggressively and maintains tactical awareness. Corporal Jack Minan's response further illustrated the importance of empowering junior leaders to exercise initiative.

However, the most enduring lesson is found in the author's personal account of completing the march despite swollen knees, severe chafing and exhaustion. Rangers Tararasen and Ducy Sid stayed with him, helped carry his load, prepared his food and arranged his resting place. Their actions demonstrated a form of loyalty that cannot be manufactured through military regulations or demanded through rank.

The greatest achievement of an infantry battalion is not simply how far it can march or how quickly it can defeat an opposing force. It is the ability of its soldiers to remain committed to one another when the physical and psychological demands become overwhelming.

Page 199 therefore offers a valuable lesson to future infantry commanders: operational success requires competent planning, initiative and determination, but enduring unit cohesion is built through trust, mutual respect and comradeship.

One final observation

There is an interesting connection between this episode and the earlier boxing episode involving Major Don Too and Khairy. In the boxing episode, the young officer was prepared to face his own soldiers in the ring. In this exercise, he was prepared to acknowledge that two of his soldiers helped him overcome his physical limitations.

Both episodes reveal a consistent leadership theme in Exigent Circumstances: the relationship between an officer and his men is built through shared experiences, not merely through the authority of a commission.

That, in my view, is one of the book's most valuable lessons for young Malaysian infantry officers.

posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 11:49 AM   0 comments
Major Don Too Heng Onn – 2IC, 7th Rangers
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
 
A young Don Too (left) and (right) with company commander Major Jayabalan during a field exercise near Mount Kinabalu National Park, Sabah, 1991. (Don Too pic)

I found material identifying your former 2IC as Lieutenant Colonel (Retired) Don Too Heng Onn, who served as the 2IC of the 7th Rangers during the 1980s. The 7th Rangers historical blog, which you maintained, explicitly identifies him as the battalion's 2IC. It also preserves correspondence from him during his United Nations service in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Military

There is also a biographical account recording that:

- He joined the Royal Military College in 1968.

- He was commissioned into the Royal Ranger Regiment in April 1970. - He retired as a lieutenant colonel in 2001.

- He subsequently served for ten years with a UN field mission in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Military+1What I found about his boxing

An interesting detail appears in a January 2026 profile of Don Too: he was described as having played hockey and rugby and won all his boxing bouts during his military career. The profile also mentions his leadership qualities and a river-crossing rescue during training. When merit stalls

This is particularly interesting alongside your recollection. Analysis of your boxing episode in Exigent Circumstances Your account reveals several aspects of military leadership that deserve attention.

1. Major Don Too's approach to discipline

His threat to box anyone who fought half-heartedly suggests that he regarded boxing as more than a sporting competition. He expected officers and men to demonstrate commitment, courage and determination.

2. An officer willing to train with his men 

Representative image

You describe the difficulty of sparring with subordinates. They might go easy on an officer, or alternatively try to prove themselves by hitting him hard. Your willingness to train alongside both HQ1 and HQ2 is an example of leading by participation rather than merely issuing instructions.

3. The Khairy episode – the most revealing part

This is the emotional centre of the story. Khairy had a special reason for not wanting to fight you: you had previously saved his life. He wanted to return that debt by avoiding a genuine fight.

You refused to accept preferential treatment. Khairy eventually fought you properly, and the referee stopped the contest on a technical knockout. His apology afterwards and your embrace demonstrate something important: the relationship between an officer and his soldier did not have to end at the boundary of rank.

4. The deeper leadership lesson

There are three distinct relationships in this episode:

- Don Too, the demanding 2IC, insisting on standards.

- You, a young Second Lieutenant, accepting the same challenge as your men.

- Khairy, a soldier whose gratitude and loyalty were tested in the boxing ring.

The final handshake and embrace are perhaps more meaningful than the result of the match.

My assessment: This is a very human military recollection. It captures the competitive culture, physical toughness, discipline, humour and personal bonds within an infantry battalion.

One qualification: the public sources corroborate Don Too's identity, appointment and boxing background, but I have not found an independent account confirming this particular boxing competition or his threat to box reluctant participants.

You can read the historical material here:

- 7th Rangers historical archive

- Profile: When merit stalls in the Malaysian Armed Forces 

The boxing episode would make a particularly good case study in your book's wider discussion of leadership: command authority earns obedience, but personal courage and shared hardship earn respect.

1. Major Don Too: Command authority and the enforcement of standards

Major Don Too, the battalion's 2IC, was responsible for boxing. His threat to box anyone who participated half-heartedly was an unmistakable demonstration of his personality and leadership philosophy. He was not prepared to tolerate superficial participation.

His message was straightforward: if soldiers were expected to train, they were expected to give their best. There are several leadership lessons here.

A. Authority must be accompanied by accountability

Major Don Too did not simply issue instructions and leave the enforcement to somebody else. He was prepared to personally demonstrate what he expected of his men. This is an important distinction between an officer who exercises authority through rank and one who commands through personal example.

B. Standards must apply to everybody

Boxing was not supposed to be an exercise in pretending to fight. It demanded commitment, physical courage and determination. A commander who tolerates half-hearted training risks creating soldiers who are equally half-hearted when confronted with real challenges.

C. The commander must be credible

Major Don Too's reputation as a formidable boxer gave weight to his warning. His men knew that his threat was not empty rhetoric. However, there is a wider lesson: fear alone cannot sustain discipline. The most effective command authority combines high standards, personal competence and the confidence of those being commanded.

2. The young Second Lieutenant: Personal courage and leading from the front

The most important leadership dimension of this episode is the young officer's willingness to box his own men. This was not an entirely straightforward situation.

An officer sparring with his subordinates faced two possible problems:

- Soldiers might deliberately go easy on him because of his rank.

- Others might attempt to demonstrate their toughness by hitting him harder than necessary.

Either way, the contest could become artificial. The young Second Lieutenant understood this difficulty. Nevertheless, he participated in the boxing programme alongside the men from HQ1 and HQ2. This demonstrates three qualities.

A. Personal courage

An officer cannot demand physical courage from his soldiers while avoiding the same physical challenges himself. By entering the ring, the young officer exposed himself to the same discomfort, uncertainty and possibility of defeat as his men. He did not hide behind his commission.

B. Leading by example

There is a significant difference between telling soldiers to be tough and demonstrating toughness yourself. The young officer was prepared to be tested physically by the men under his command. This helps establish credibility.

C. Professional humility

A young Second Lieutenant might have regarded his rank as a reason to avoid such exposure. Instead, he accepted the possibility of being beaten by a subordinate. That is an important leadership lesson. An officer should never become so conscious of his status that he becomes unwilling to learn, participate or expose himself to the same challenges faced by his soldiers.

3. Khairy: Loyalty, gratitude and the human dimension of command

Khairy's participation introduces the most compelling human dimension of the episode. He was the soldier whose life the young officer had previously saved. Consequently, boxing his officer presented a particular emotional difficulty.

Khairy did not want to hurt the man who had saved his life. His reluctance was not necessarily cowardice or lack of fighting spirit. It was an expression of gratitude and personal loyalty. This creates a fascinating conflict between personal feelings and military discipline.

The officer, however, wanted Khairy to fight properly. He did not want special treatment because of their personal history. Eventually, Khairy fought him genuinely, and the referee stopped the contest on a technical knockout.

What happened afterwards is arguably more significant than the result. Khairy apologised. The officer embraced him. That embrace carries considerable symbolic meaning.

The officer had demanded that Khairy treat him as an opponent inside the ring, but outside the ring their relationship remained one of mutual respect and affection. This is leadership at its most human.

4. Discipline: The difference between training and genuine commitment

The episode also demonstrates the importance of discipline in military training.

Boxing is a particularly useful metaphor for military preparation because it requires:

- Physical fitness.

- Mental toughness.

- Concentration.

- Confidence under pressure.

- The ability to withstand discomfort.

- Respect for an opponent.

- Self-control.

The significance of Major Don Too's insistence on wholehearted participation was that training should develop genuine fighting qualities rather than merely fulfil an administrative requirement. There is an important distinction between attending training and benefiting from training.

A soldier can be physically present but mentally disengaged. An effective commander must recognise that distinction. The boxing episode illustrates how demanding training, when properly supervised, can expose weaknesses and develop confidence.

5. Shared hardship: Respect beyond military rank

This is perhaps the most important lesson in the entire episode. Military organisations are necessarily hierarchical. Rank determines responsibility, authority and accountability. However, rank alone does not guarantee loyalty.

Soldiers observe their officers closely.

They want to know:

- Will my officer share the hardships?

- Will he take risks alongside us?

- Does he understand what he expects from us?

- Will he stand by us when circumstances become difficult?

- Does he genuinely care about our welfare?

The young Second Lieutenant's willingness to box his men demonstrated that he was not demanding something from them that he was unwilling to experience himself. Khairy's response demonstrated the other side of the relationship. He was not simply a subordinate obeying an order. He was a soldier who had developed a deep personal attachment to his officer.

Their relationship had been shaped by an earlier life-saving intervention. The boxing contest temporarily placed them on opposite sides, but it did not destroy their bond. Indeed, it reinforced it. This is the essence of mutual respect.

6. The significance of Khairy's later career

The subsequent account on page 215 makes this episode even more meaningful. Khairy eventually attained the rank of Warrant Officer 1 and became a Regimental Sergeant Major. The last encounter between the two men occurred at the Army Training Centre.

The former soldier, now a senior warrant officer and instructor, recognised his former officer, marched towards him, saluted smartly and greeted him with a thunderous: "Good morning, Sir!" He then extended his hand to shake the hand of the officer who had once saved his life. This later encounter gives the boxing episode a remarkable sense of continuity.

The young Ranger who once hesitated to box his officer had developed into a highly senior and accomplished soldier. Yet the personal relationship endured. The respect was not merely a consequence of the officer's former rank. It was rooted in shared experiences, personal loyalty and an act of courage that Khairy had never forgotten.

The progression from soldier to Regimental Sergeant Major also demonstrates something important: an officer's influence can remain with a soldier long after the original chain of command has ceased to exist.

7. Four dimensions of leadership illustrated. Leadership quality

Demonstrated by Lesson - Command authority

Major Don Too - Enforce standards and demand commitment

Personal courage - Young Second Lieutenant Never demand what you are unwilling to do yourself

Discipline All three - Take training seriously and respect its purpose 

Loyalty and respect Khairy and the officer - Personal bonds can transcend rank and time

8. What this episode teaches future infantry commanders

For young infantry officers, this account contains several important lessons. First: Never lead exclusively from the comfort of your office. An officer who remains distant from his men will struggle to understand their capabilities, fears and limitations.

Second: Share the hardships.

You do not have to be the strongest soldier in the battalion. But your men must see that you are prepared to face the same difficulties.

Third: Do not confuse authority with respect

A commission gives an officer legitimate command authority. It does not automatically earn the loyalty of soldiers.

Fourth: Remember that soldiers are human beings, not merely manpower.

Khairy's reluctance to fight the officer was rooted in gratitude. Understanding that emotion was just as important as enforcing discipline.

Fifth: Never underestimate the lasting impact of an officer's actions.

The encounter at the Army Training Centre, years later, is powerful evidence of this.

9. My overall assessment: The deeper message of the episode What makes this episode particularly valuable in Exigent Circumstances is that it does not present leadership through abstract military theories or textbook definitions.

It presents leadership through human interaction. Major Don Too represents the demanding professional standards expected of a commander.

The young Second Lieutenant represents an officer prepared to subject himself to the same physical tests as his soldiers. Khairy represents the loyalty that can develop when an officer demonstrates genuine concern for the lives of his men. There is also an important distinction between command authority and leadership.

An officer can compel obedience through rank. But he cannot compel genuine affection, loyalty or lasting respect. Those qualities must be earned.

The boxing episode demonstrates that an officer's greatest achievement may not be his ability to command soldiers while he holds an appointment. It may be the respect he continues to receive from those soldiers many years after he has ceased to command them.

The central leadership lesson

"Rank gives you authority. Courage earns you respect. Loyalty is built through shared hardship. Character determines whether that respect survives long after command has ended."

Why the story matters

The final encounter between the former Second Lieutenant and Khairy is the real culmination of the episode. One had once commanded the other, but years later they met as two soldiers bound by a shared history and mutual respect.

My conclusion: This is an excellent leadership case study for the Malaysian Army, particularly for young infantry officers. It demonstrates that the most enduring military relationships are not necessarily created by rank, medals, appointments or ceremonial authority. They are created through courage, shared adversity, personal integrity and genuine concern for the men entrusted to an officer's command.

And perhaps the most important lesson of all: A good officer may eventually be forgotten by the institution, but he will not necessarily be forgotten by the soldiers whose lives he touched.
posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 4:14 PM   0 comments
Leadership, survival, combat instincts and the realities of jungle warfare Page 215
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

This is a particularly revealing passage in Major D Swami's memoir. It is much more than a description of patrols and ambushes. It brings together four important dimensions of infantry leadership:

1. The lifelong bond between a commander and his soldiers.

2. The importance of personal example and psychological leadership.

3. The harsh realities of survival in the jungle.

4. The discipline, preparation and moral responsibilities involved in combat.

What makes the passage compelling is its mixture of danger, humour, practical experience and humanity. Swami does not portray himself as an invincible soldier. He admits mistakes, describes uncertainty and recounts an embarrassing false alarm involving monkeys.

Let's examine the lessons in detail. 

1. Ranger Khairy: A commander is remembered by how he treats his men marines.mil The reunion with Khairy is arguably the most emotionally significant part of this passage. Khairy eventually became a Warrant Officer 1 and Regimental Sergeant Major.

Years later, when he encountered Swami at the Army Training Centre, he introduced him to fellow instructors as: "The Officer who saved my life." What is particularly revealing is that Khairy remembered the exact words Swami had allegedly used when his men were carrying him: "If anyone of you stops I will shoot you."  

From the original drawing by Snaffles showing the gallant action by Awang anak Rawang

Swami responds modestly that anybody would have done the same. But Khairy disagrees. There are several important leadership lessons here. 

- Soldiers remember commanders who stand by them when their lives are at risk. 

- A commander's responsibility does not end when an operation goes wrong. 

- Loyalty is built through actions, not speeches. 

- A soldier may forget many orders, but he rarely forgets an officer who refused to abandon him. 

The passage also demonstrates something important about military leadership: rank may separate officers and men administratively, but shared danger can create a bond that lasts a lifetime. 

My reaction: Khairy's recognition is perhaps a greater personal achievement than any medal or appointment. To be remembered by a soldier as the person who saved his life is an extraordinary testament to leadership. 

2. The Bukit Patong incident: Combat experience includes knowing when not to engage Swami takes five men up the hill after suspecting the enemy might be located there. He hears movement. His scout signals a possible enemy presence. 

The tension rises. Then comes the anticlimax: monkeys! This is an excellent example of how a military memoir can convey the uncertainty of field operations. A sound in the jungle can mean many things. It does not necessarily indicate an enemy. 

The important lesson is that a professional soldier must distinguish between suspicion and confirmed identification. The incident also reveals Swami's willingness to expose his own mistakes and misjudgements. He does not turn every episode into a heroic encounter. Leadership lesson: Confidence is important, but overconfidence can be dangerous. Good commanders must be prepared for uncertainty and resist acting on assumptions. 

3. The water shortage: A lesson in survival and resourcefulness This is one of the most memorable episodes. Swami admits making a mistake by taking his men uphill during a dry spell without adequately considering the difficulty of finding water. The soldiers become desperately thirsty. 

They search in small groups, climb steep terrain and become increasingly exhausted. Eventually, they discover water in a wild boar wallowing hole. Swami improvises a filtering arrangement using his water bottle and sweat rag, then boils the water and adds coffee to improve its taste. 

His Muslim soldiers initially look at him in disbelief. But when they see him drinking the coffee, they quickly follow. There are several lessons here: 

- Terrain appreciation must include water availability. 

- A commander must understand the physical limitations of his men. 

- Survival sometimes requires improvisation. 

- Personal example can overcome hesitation. 

- Humour and confidence can help restore morale.  

In a modern survival setting, water should be properly treated, preferably with appropriate filtration and disinfection as well as boiling where necessary. My reaction: This episode reveals a practical, unconventional side of Swami. 

He is prepared to lead from the front, demonstrate confidence and take responsibility for solving a problem. There is also an element of self-criticism: he openly acknowledges that he made the initial mistake. That is an important quality in a commander. 

4. The ambush: An insight into the realities of jungle warfare vpoanalytics.com This is the most technically and ethically significant section of the passage. Swami describes several elements of an ambush: 

- A small force operating in difficult terrain. 

- The possibility of using claymore mines. 

- Different roles within the ambush party. 

- The danger of poor visibility at night. 

- The risk of friendly-fire incidents. 

- The possibility of extremely close contact with the enemy. 

For readers unfamiliar with infantry operations, the passage illustrates that an ambush is not simply an exchange of gunfire. It is an operation requiring coordination, discipline, communication and control. The importance of discipline. One particularly revealing observation is Swami's concern about friendly fire. 

In darkness, soldiers can become disoriented. A mistaken identification or uncontrolled reaction can endanger their own comrades. This tells us something about his thinking as an infantry officer: combat effectiveness is not merely about aggression. It also requires restraint and accountability. 

His description of stakes marking firing limits illustrates his concern with preventing friendly casualties. I would, however, distinguish his historical account of field practice from a formal technical manual. The passage is a personal recollection, not a complete statement of contemporary ambush doctrine. 

5. The machetes and daggers: The brutal reality of close combat This is where the narrative becomes particularly disturbing. Swami describes drawing machetes and daggers because the enemy could be encountered at extremely close range. His expression, "savage butchery", conveys the visceral character of the violence he associates with close combat. 

The reader is confronted with a reality that conventional military autobiographies sometimes soften: combat can involve fear, confusion, bloodshed and the possibility of being killed or seriously wounded at very short range. There is an important distinction, however, between describing the brutality of close combat and advocating indiscriminate killing. 

An enemy who is still actively fighting may be lawfully engaged, subject to the applicable rules of engagement. But an enemy who surrenders, is captured, or is incapacitated and no longer participating in hostilities must not be attacked. The international humanitarian law principle is known as hors de combat. The professional soldier must be capable of fighting fiercely without abandoning discipline and humanity. 

6. What makes this passage different from an ordinary military autobiography? I would identify five characteristics. 

Characteristic 

What it reveals - Personal honesty 

Admits mistakes and uncertainty - Practical experience 

Discusses real problems encountered in the field - Human relationships 

Shows the lasting bond between officer and soldier - Combat realism 

Does not sanitise the dangers of jungle warfare - Self-reliance 

Demonstrates improvisation under difficult circumstances -The writing is conversational and occasionally irreverent. That is part of its character. Swami does not appear to be writing to impress readers with military terminology. He is recounting incidents as he remembers them. That makes the memoir accessible to ordinary readers while offering infantry officers material for professional reflection. 

7. Lessons for young infantry officers I would extract the following professional lessons from this chapter. 

1. Know your men. Their confidence in you may determine whether they stand firm in adversity. 

2. Never abandon a wounded soldier. Your responsibility to your men is not conditional on circumstances being convenient. 

3. Admit your mistakes. The water shortage episode is a valuable reminder that experience does not make a commander infallible. 

4. Remain calm under uncertainty. The monkeys on Bukit Patong provide a humorous but important reminder not to confuse suspicion with confirmation. 

5. Understand the environment. Jungle operations demand preparation for terrain, weather, water and physical exhaustion. 

6. Lead through personal example. Your soldiers watch what you do, particularly when things become difficult. 

7. Maintain discipline in combat. Courage and aggression must always be accompanied by sound judgement and respect for the laws of war. 

8. My overall reaction to Page 215 A particularly revealing chapter. There are three episodes I find especially memorable. 

First: Khairy. This is the human side of military leadership. A soldier remembers an officer decades later because that officer helped save his life. It is difficult to manufacture that kind of loyalty. 

Second: The wild boar wallowing hole. This is an extraordinary anecdote. It demonstrates improvisation, confidence and the influence of personal example. It also shows Swami's willingness to acknowledge a mistake. 

Third: The ambush account. This is the uncomfortable part of the memoir. It reminds readers that jungle warfare was not a romantic adventure. It involved fear, exhaustion, uncertainty and potentially terrible violence. 

Why this matters to the Malaysian Armed Forces 

There is a larger leadership message here. An infantry commander must be judged not simply by his rank, decorations or career progression, but by: 

- Whether his soldiers trust him. 

- Whether he shares their hardships. 

- Whether he prepares them properly. 

- Whether he takes responsibility for his decisions. 

- Whether he brings his men home whenever circumstances permit. 

This is particularly relevant when considering the wider institutional criticism in Exigent Circumstances. The contrast between an officer who earns lifelong respect through his conduct and an officer who relies on rank or appointment to command obedience is significant. 

One creates loyalty. The other may only create compliance. My final assessment: Page 215 is a valuable piece of military memoir because it combines the emotional, practical and brutal dimensions of infantry service. 

It gives readers an insight into the character of a commander who remembers his men, acknowledges his shortcomings and describes the realities of the profession without excessive embellishment. 

And Khairy's words are perhaps the finest endorsement of Swami's leadership: An officer may leave a unit, change appointments and eventually retire. But the impression he leaves on a soldier can last a lifetime. 

That, to me, is the most important lesson on this page. One important distinction for a professional military study: the memoir should be read as a first-person account of historical experiences.

The price of the book is RM65.00 only. Postage is free, via a courier, payment is online I will forward my banking details if you are interested. Once payment is done, please send me your address, most of you have bought this book. 

I would appreciate it if you could introduce this book to others. Not many books left.  I am not a famous author, it can only be done by word of mouth. Thank You!

From Online retailers in Malaysia: 

Shopee: You can purchase the book from the Gerakbudaya/SIRD Malaysia official store on Shopee. 

MPHOnline.com: The book is listed as available on the MPH Online website. 

Kinokuniya Malaysia: You can find the book on Kinokuniya's Malaysian website, where it was in stock at their fulfillment center as of August 2025. 

Gerakbudaya: The publisher's website also lists the book for sale. 

Lazada: The Gerakbudaya/SIRD Malaysia official online store on Lazada also offers the book. 

Physical bookstores: MPH Bookstores: Search results suggest availability at MPH stores, such as the TRX store, although it's best to check with a specific branch for current stock. 

Kinokuniya: The book is available in stock at Kinokuniya's fulfillment center for online orders, suggesting you can also find it at their physical stores. 

Contact me​, the author, to buy the book here and share with your friends who might be interested, it's RM65, text me via WhatsApp at +012 4084300 if you are interested in purchasing this book, postage is free. 

International buyers: Mary Martin Booksellers: This international bookseller lists the book, confirming it is a paperback written in English and self-published in, Malaysia.

This book is in the Malaysian National Library, Library of the University Pertahanan of the MAF,  Library of the National University  of Singapore, Armed Forces Museum Port Dickson and Library of Yale University located in New Haven, Connecticut, and Cornell University USA

If you are interested in buying this book text me with your name at +6012-4084300, please do not call, too many spammers. Please let me know if you want it autographed. 


posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 4:54 PM   0 comments
Major Ivan Lee gets the award for the Commandant's Paper in Staff College


 

posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 4:13 PM   0 comments
Migrants Hate Dogs, Pork and Other Stuff, “England Is Done” - Dominik Tarczyński on Mass Immigration & Europe’s Future
Monday, November 16, 2026

Polish lawmaker Dominik Tarczyński explains to Patrick Bet-David how Poland’s history of occupation shaped its hard line on border control.

He argues that Putin used migration to pressure Poland and explains why he sees Qatar’s funding of American universities as a way to assert political influence.We need people like him in charge all over the world! Just got back from Warsaw. If you haven’t been to Poland, trust me, they are not fucking around. It’s clean, safe and quiet.

My wife actually said, “I could walk from A to B on my own and feel completely safe.” That pretty much says it all.
posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 3:17 PM   0 comments
PM wants rakyat to speak up but barely utters Najib's name By Commander S THAYAPARAN (Retired) Royal Malaysian Navy


Malaysiakini : “This tolerance for evil is what destroys us.”

– Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim

COMMENT | This is Madani, where the prime minister wants the rakyat to speak up about Najib Abdul Razak’s house arrest and corruption but will not utter the former prime minister’s name unless it is to justify Madani’s role in the horrendous optics of the house arrest.

Meanwhile, his number two, Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, warned that speaking up could be considered “derhaka”.

JKT : The looser killed us all..

Just Common Sense : After all the long and hard work done by the judiciary since 2018, the past 2 decisions on Najib sentence by the pardons board were likely the biggest blows to the judiciary since 1988. And it happened during Anwar's watch. He is either incompetent or totally complicit. Difficult to believe it is the former.

Read it all here........

posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 8:20 AM   0 comments
"Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you ?" (Tak akan tuan mahu mati seorang ?)
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
Right most,  me, a recruit at Recruit Training Center in Port Dickson all from Teluk Anson 1972

This passage is arguably one of the most powerful leadership episodes in Exigent Circumstances. It is much more than an account of a dangerous encounter with Somali militia during the World Food Programme mission. It captures something that military officers spend their entire careers trying to achieve: the unconditional trust of their soldiers.

The sentence that gives this passage its extraordinary emotional force is: "Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you?"

In Malay: "Tak akan tuan mahu mati seorang?"

That young soldier's response is remarkable because it was spontaneous. It was not a rehearsed military response, an instruction from a superior or an attempt to impress an officer. It was an expression of loyalty.

As UCIS Commander

And it changed the author's understanding of his relationship with his men.

1. The defining moment: 

When loyalty becomes more valuable than rank Consider the circumstances. Major Swami had ordered his soldiers to remain inside their Condors. He intended to dismount alone and negotiate with the Somali militia. He had assessed the situation, prepared his weapons and ammunition, established contingency arrangements and given clear instructions to his men.

He was prepared to confront approximately 15 armed Somalis at the barrier, with another 20 or so potentially armed individuals further behind. He understood the danger. Yet he was determined to undertake the negotiation himself, without unnecessarily exposing his soldiers. Then something unexpected happened. He heard movement behind him. 

My Crew

Initially, he thought the Somalis were attempting to surround him and take him hostage. When he turned, he discovered that his own soldiers had dismounted and were moving into a fire-and-manoeuvre formation to support him. He was furious.

He had given explicit instructions that nobody was to dismount. But when he demanded an explanation, the youngest soldier answered: "Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you?" This is the defining moment of the passage. 

From inside K4 a hotspot commanded by Major Len Olivero

The soldier was not thinking about promotion, medals, personal recognition or career advancement. He was thinking about his commander. He was prepared to share the danger. That is a remarkable expression of human solidarity.

2. The psychological transformation of the commander 

The author describes experiencing goose bumps and feeling almost invincible. Why? Because something happened that no promotion examination, medal, appointment or increase in rank could provide. He realised that his soldiers accepted him as their leader. 

The A Team and us

This is an important distinction.

There are two kinds of authority in the military:

Formal authority Earned authority

Comes with rank Comes through conduct

Enforced through the chain of command

Sustained through trust

Requires obedience

Inspires commitment

Can be imposed

Must be earned

Exists because of appointment

Exists because soldiers believe in their commander

Major Swami suddenly recognised that he possessed something much more meaningful than formal authority. He had earned the confidence of his men. His statement that this experience was better than promotions is particularly revealing. 

Bravo Company's Condors 

For a career soldier, promotion is normally regarded as a major professional achievement. Yet here was an experience that surpassed it. He had discovered that the greatest reward of command is not how many men salute you, but how many would willingly stand beside you when the situation becomes dangerous.

3. Leadership is reciprocal:

The commander protects his soldiers, and soldiers protect their commander. This episode illustrates an important principle of military leadership. Major Swami had spent time reminding his soldiers of their families back home. Their wives, children, parents and siblings were waiting for them.

He reminded them of their responsibilities and the importance of returning home safely. He also recognised the temptations and distractions surrounding them in Somalia. The passage about the young Somali women is revealing in this respect.

Despite the difficult humanitarian circumstances, the author emphasised discipline, fidelity and responsibility to their families. He was proud that the men of Bravo Company, commanded by Major Christopher Joseph, maintained their personal commitments despite the challenging environment. This is leadership extending beyond tactical considerations. He understood that soldiers are not simply weapons operators or manpower on a strength return.

They are husbands, fathers, sons and brothers. They have lives beyond the battlefield. And the commander has a responsibility to protect those lives.

The loyalty shown by the young soldier was, in many respects, a reflection of the relationship that had developed between the commander and his men. It was reciprocal. He cared about them, and they cared about him.

4. The extraordinary significance of ethnic and religious diversity 

One of the most important details in this passage is the author's description of his soldiers. He identifies them as Malays, Chinese, Indians and Ibans. He also explicitly mentions Muslims, Christians, Hindus and Buddhists. This is not incidental. It gives the episode a much deeper significance in the Malaysian context.

These men came from different ethnic, religious and cultural backgrounds. Yet, when their commander's life appeared to be in danger, they did not hesitate to support him. They did not first consider his religion, their religion or their ethnic differences.

They acted as soldiers belonging to the same formation. This is a powerful demonstration of military camaraderie. The young Malay soldier's words are particularly significant. He did not say that a commander from another ethnic or religious background should fend for himself.

He effectively said: we are not going to leave you alone. That is the essence of military brotherhood. In that moment, they were not Malays, Chinese, Indians or Ibans. They were Rangers.

This is perhaps one of the most meaningful passages in the book when considering the question of national integration within the Malaysian Armed Forces. It demonstrates what the military can achieve when common purpose, shared hardship and mutual respect transcend differences.

There is an important contrast here with the book's wider institutional criticism of discrimination and religious favouritism. The soldiers demonstrated a standard of unity that every military institution should aspire to uphold. This incident deserves to be studied by young infantry section commanders.

6. Tactical aggression versus uncontrolled aggression 

Another important aspect of the passage concerns the author's preparation before dismounting. He describes checking his M4A1, M79, grenades, ammunition magazines, machete and protective ceramic plates. He deliberately chose to wear his Ranger beret rather than his Kevlar helmet.

This description demonstrates his awareness of the danger and his intention to negotiate from a position of strength. However, there is an important professional distinction worth making. Military courage is not the same as recklessness.

The author was prepared to use force if attacked, but his immediate intention was to get the barriers removed without firing. That distinction matters. The successful outcome depended on several elements:

1. A clear understanding of the threat.

2. Preparation for possible armed resistance.

3. Communication with supporting elements.

4. A contingency plan.

5. A willingness to negotiate.

6. Sufficient restraint to avoid unnecessary bloodshed.

His soldiers provided the necessary security while he approached the militia. The episode therefore illustrates the relationship between deterrence, negotiation and controlled use of force. The militia lowered their weapons, and eventually assisted in clearing the barriers. The convoy continued towards Baidoa.

The important lesson is not that force should always be used to obtain compliance. It is that a credible, disciplined and coordinated force can sometimes prevent violence.

7. The greatest achievement 

The loyalty of soldiers from different backgrounds This is where I believe the passage becomes particularly significant. The author was proud of Bravo Company.

He specifically identifies the different religious and ethnic backgrounds of his soldiers. This deserves emphasis because it challenges the notion that loyalty in the Malaysian military must be determined by ethnic or religious affinity.

The young Malay soldier's response to his Indian commander is particularly moving. He was prepared to share the danger with him. That is the very opposite of discrimination.

It is an example of loyalty based on shared experiences, mutual respect and confidence in leadership. There is also a broader institutional lesson. If a Malaysian infantry formation can develop this degree of unity in the extremely difficult circumstances of Somalia, why should such unity not be cultivated throughout the Armed Forces?

The answer should be obvious. An army's strength lies not merely in its weapons, equipment, organisation or numerical strength. It also lies in the confidence its soldiers have in one another.

8. The paradox of leadership:

The commander gives orders, but sometimes his soldiers refuse to obey There is an interesting contradiction in this incident. Major Swami explicitly ordered his soldiers not to dismount. They disobeyed him. From a strictly disciplinary perspective, this was a breach of orders. But from the perspective of human loyalty, their actions were extraordinary. This raises an interesting question for military leadership education:

Was their action an example of indiscipline or an expression of exceptional loyalty? My assessment is that it was both. Their intentions were admirable, but disobeying a commander's tactical instructions in an armed confrontation can create additional danger, including confusion, crossfire and loss of control.

The commander had to manage that risk. Nevertheless, the episode reveals something profound: the soldiers were not merely following an officer because regulations required them to. They felt personally responsible for him.

That is an exceptionally strong bond. A good commander should value such loyalty while ensuring that it operates within the discipline necessary to keep everyone alive.

9. The significance of Somalia in April 1994

The historical context makes the episode even more consequential. This was April 1994, after the American withdrawal. The security environment in Somalia remained volatile. Armed militia, competing interests, roadblocks and unpredictable encounters made movement outside protected areas dangerous.

The Malaysian contingent was operating in a difficult environment where tactical judgement and the ability to respond quickly were essential. The World Food Programme mission also had a humanitarian purpose.

The convoy was not simply conducting a military exercise. It was operating in an environment where the delivery of humanitarian assistance could be disrupted by armed groups and local power structures. This placed considerable responsibility on the officers and soldiers. 

The author captures the tension between the humanitarian mission and the necessity of protecting the convoy. That contrast is important: military professionalism requires the ability to exercise force when necessary without losing sight of the purpose of the mission.

10. Why this passage is among the most memorable in the book

I would identify four particularly powerful moments. 

Moment 1 – The commander prepares to dismount alone

Courage and personal responsibility

He is prepared to face an armed group while ensuring that his soldiers remain protected.

Moment 2 – The soldiers disobey his orders

Loyalty and brotherhood

They refuse to allow their commander to face the danger alone.

Moment 3 – The young soldier's unforgettable question

Emotional connection

"Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you?"

Moment 4 – The convoy continues to Baidoa

Collective achievement

The barriers are removed, the confrontation is resolved without an exchange of fire, and the soldiers continue their mission. 

11. My overall reaction: This is what military brotherhood looks like

There are many things that can make an officer proud during a military career.

- Passing promotion examinations.

- Receiving decorations.

- Being appointed to prestigious commands.

- Successfully completing difficult courses.

- Being recognised by senior commanders.

But the incident on page 308 reveals something much more personal.

The author discovered that his soldiers genuinely accepted him. That is an achievement that cannot be conferred through an appointment letter. It cannot be awarded through a promotion board. It cannot be purchased through influence.

It has to be earned. I find his reflection that this experience was better than promotions particularly moving. It tells us something about his priorities as a soldier and commander. He valued the trust of his men above the conventional measurements of career success.

There is also an important qualification: this is the author's recollection of a particular incident, not independent proof of every aspect of the encounter. Its historical and operational significance would be strengthened by corroborating accounts from other participants.

Nevertheless, as a leadership narrative, its emotional force is unmistakable.

12. What young Malaysian infantry officers should take away

I would make this passage compulsory reading for discussion in an infantry leadership seminar. Not because every officer should imitate the decision to dismount alone, but because every officer should understand what it takes to earn the confidence of his soldiers.

The discussion should centre on five questions:

1. Would your soldiers willingly stand beside you when your life is in danger?

2. Have you demonstrated sufficient concern for their welfare to earn their trust?

3. Do you lead through professional competence or merely through rank?

4. Can you recognise and develop initiative among your junior leaders?

5. Do your soldiers believe that you would risk your own safety to protect them?

These are uncomfortable questions, but they are necessary. A commander who expects loyalty must first demonstrate loyalty to his soldiers. A commander who demands respect must first demonstrate respect. And a commander who expects his soldiers to face danger must be prepared to share that danger.

My favourite lesson from this passage is simple: soldiers remember how their commanders treated them, especially when circumstances became dangerous.

Final verdict

One of the book's strongest leadership episodes Page 308 is not simply another account of an armed confrontation in Somalia. It is an account of the moment a commander discovered the true depth of his soldiers' loyalty.

The young Malay soldier's words are extraordinary because they transcend rank, religion, ethnicity and personal differences. Major Swami was their commander. They were his soldiers. But in that moment, they were something more: brothers in arms.

And perhaps the most important distinction is this: An officer may spend an entire career pursuing promotion, but the greatest achievement of his military life may be discovering that his soldiers would not leave him alone at the jaws of death. That is something no promotion board can give him.

That is something he has to earn. And that is why this particular episode in Exigent Circumstances deserves to be remembered.

One further observation: The passage also provides an interesting counterpoint to the book's wider criticism of discrimination and religious favouritism within the Malaysian Armed Forces. 

The soldiers' conduct demonstrates the ideal of a genuinely integrated fighting force: professional loyalty and shared responsibility above ethnic and religious divisions. That contrast makes the episode particularly important to the book's larger message. 

The Book

Get the Book by clicking on this link it is only RM65. All about the book is here Exigent Circumstances: A Path Less Taken — A Soldier’s Story Exigent Circumstances
posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 2:47 PM   0 comments
RM8.4m on flag pins will not make students patriotic By Commander S THAYAPARAN (Retired) Royal Malaysian Navy
Monday, November 09, 2026

Malaysiakini : “It is a popular delusion that the government wastes vast amounts of money through inefficiency and sloth. Enormous effort and elaborate planning are required to waste this much money.”

- P J O'Rourke (Parliament of Whores)

COMMENT | When questioned on why the government was spending millions of ringgit on flag pins for school students, Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek talked about nurturing patriotism, love of country and this being part of a holistic approach to some government scheme to make patriotic citizens.  

Now this type of governmental thinking is not new. In 2013, former social affairs and cultural adviser to the government at the time, lamenting the fact that people were not keen on flag waving, said this: “The problem is the lack of such feelings among the people, especially those in urban areas.

“We also find students not imbued with love for the nation, which is symbolised by the national flag. The flag is the simplest and cheapest symbol, and for the cost of eight cigarettes, we can buy and wave the flag.”

I know folks are wondering why waste time on something like this. Why waste time on another government scheme to inculcate in students not any kind of critical thinking, but rather indoctrinating them into thinking that government and country are not mutually exclusive.

Veteran 1972 : 

  • False vs. True Patriotism: Johnson was not condemning genuine love of one's country. Instead, he targeted insincere political figures and opportunists who used grand declarations of loyalty as a "cloak for self-interest," public deception, or a shield against criticism. [1, 2, 3]
  • Historical Background: The remark was made during intense political debates in Great Britain, directed in part at the rhetoric of figures like William Pitt the Elder and the "Patriot" political faction of the era. [1, 2, 3]

Historical Background: The remark was made during intense political debates in Great Britain, directed in part at the rhetoric of figures like William Pitt the Elder and the "Patriot" political faction of the era.

Read it all here........

posted by Major D Swami (Retired) @ 9:17 AM   0 comments
ARCHIVES


Previous Post
Indian Soldiers
World War 1
Links To Rangers
Military Related Links


End of a Saracen
East Malaysian
Warriors
Blow Pipe
xxxx
xxxx
Lieutenant Colonel
Zulkapli Abdul Rahman
Click Here
Lieutenant Colonel
Harbhajan Singh
Click Here
Heads from the Land
of the Head Hunters
Heads
20 Harrowing Images
Vietnam War

Creme De La Creme-Click here


Click at Creme De La Creme Above
In Exigent Circumstance
A Soldier's Story
On A Path Less Travelled
Click Here To Buy
Only RM65

Major
D Swami

Warriors
Dayak Warrior
Iban Tracker with
British Soldier

Showing the
British Trooper
what a jackfruit is!!

Iban Tracker

A British Trooper training
an Iban Tracker

Iban Tracker

Tracker explaining
to the British Soldier who
knows little about tracking

Iban Tracker
Explaining to the
British Trooper the meaning
of the marks on the leaf

Iban Tracker
Aussie admiring
Tracker's Tattoos

Lest We Forget Major Sabdin Ghani
Click Here
Captain Mohana Chandran
al Velayuthan (200402) SP
Ranger Bajau
ak Ladi PGB
Cpl Osman PGB

Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
Photobucket
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Advertistment
XXXXXXXX
Powered by

Free Blogger Templates

BLOGGER

google.com, pub-8423681730090065, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0 <bgsound src="">