Most recently in France, on Mar. 16, 2023, a Muslim man smashed
a church’s six foot tall Plexiglas cross—which had stood since the
1600s—into pieces. A week earlier, also in France, another Muslim man
broke off and desecrated the crucifixes affixed to some 30 graves.
A couple weeks before that, in neighboring Belgium, a 16-year-old convert to Islam arrested on terrorist related charges had earlier videotaped himself smashing crucifixes.
What is it about the cross that prompts such behavior?
For starters, not only is it the symbol of Christianity; it also
symbolizes the fundamental disagreement between Christians and Muslims.
As Historian Sidney Griffith explains, “[t]he cross … publicly declared
those very points of Christian faith which the Koran, in the Muslim
view, explicitly denied: that Christ was the Son of God and that he died
on the cross.” Accordingly, the cross “often aroused the disdain of
Muslims,” so that from the start of the seventh century Muslim conquests
of Christian lands, there was an ongoing “campaign to erase the public
symbols of Christianity, especially the previously ubiquitous sign of
the cross.”
Testimonies abound from the very earliest invasions into Christian
Syria and Egypt of Muslims systematically breaking every crucifix they
encountered. According to Anastasius of Sinai, who lived during the
seventh century Arab conquests, “the demons name the Saracens
[Arabs/Muslims] as their companions. And it is with reason. The latter
are perhaps even worse than the demons,” for whereas “the demons are
frequently much afraid of the mysteries of Christ”—among which he
mentions the cross—“these demons of flesh trample all that under their
feet, mock it, set fire to it, destroy it”
The comparison to demons is not without significance. Last year in
Pakistan, for example, a Muslim man named Muhammed climbed atop and
wrapped himself around a large cross on church property and started
spasmodically swinging his body in an attempt to bring it down—all while
reciting Koran verses, shouting Islam’s jihadist war-cry, “Allahu Akbar,” and threatening Christians (video here).
According to the report, Muhammad was “in such a religious frenzy,” and
so “intent to tip the cross over,” that “he was risking his life to do
so.” He fell, was injured and tended to—by Christians.
Similarly, in France, after a Muslim man was arrested for destroying crosses in a graveyard, initial reports stated
that “The man repeats Muslim prayers over and over, he drools and
cannot be communicated with: his condition has been declared
incompatible with preliminary detention.” He was hospitalized as
“mentally unbalanced.”
Ironically, for Muslims, it is the cross itself that it satanic. After referring to the crucifix as “an element of the devil,”
Indonesian cleric Sheikh Abdul Somad continued his videotaped response
to the question why Muslims “felt a chill whenever they saw a crucifix,”
by saying, “Because of Satan!” Similarly, Kuwaiti cleric Othman
al-Khamis issued a fatwa
comparing the Christian crucifix to Satan, adding that crosses can only
be publicly displayed in order to mock them, for example by depicting
them “in an insulting place such as socks.” In keeping with such logic,
a Pakistani shoe-seller placed the image of the cross on the soles of his shoes, so that the crucifix might be trodden with every Muslim footstep.
As with all things Islamic, hate for the cross traces back to the
Muslim prophet Muhammad. He reportedly “had such a repugnance to the
form of the cross that he broke everything brought into his house with
its figure upon it,” to quote historian William Muir. Muhammad also
claimed that at the end times, Jesus (the Muslim “Isa”) would make it a point to “break the cross.”
When asked about Islam’s ruling on whether anyone — even a Christian —
is permitted to wear a cross, Sheikh Abdul Aziz al-Tarifi, a Saudi
expert on sharia, confirmed
the hostility: “Under no circumstances is a human permitted to wear the
cross.” Why? “Because the prophet — peace and blessings on him —
commanded the breaking of it [the cross].”
So will they replace the crosses with